IT Security

MDR vs. SOC: Choosing the Right Cybersecurity for Your Business

Patrick Wolfe
March 22, 2024

Navigating today's digital world is like sailing in unknown seas. We are excited about new technology but also face growing cyber threats. Managed detection and response (MDR) and security operations centers (SOC) are like two lighthouses, guiding and protecting us in cybersecurity.

According to Cybersecurity Ventures, it's estimated that cybercrime damages will cost the world $6 trillion annually by the end of this year, a figure that's doubled from just five years ago. This isn't just a statistic; it's a clarion call to fortify our digital defenses. MDR and SOC represent two formidable strategies in this quest but have distinct approaches and advantages. How do they stand apart, and more importantly, which aligns best with your business's unique needs and challenges? To uncover the answers, let's dive into the depths of MDR vs. SOC.


In simple terms, think of cybersecurity as a protective shield for your business. Two critical parts of this shield are managed detection and response (MDR) and security operations centers (SOC). Both are important for keeping your business safe from cyber threats, but they do different things. MDR is like having a team of experts who quickly find and stop cyber attacks. SOC is like a control room where experts watch over your business's digital safety round the clock, ready to react to any threats. Together, they form a strong defense against cyber dangers.

Understanding MDR and its role in cybersecurity

Managed detection and response (MDR) is an outsourced cybersecurity service focusing on proactive threat monitoring, detection, and rapid response. It uses advanced technologies like endpoint detection and response (EDR) and machine learning to spot potential threats before they escalate. MDR's strength lies in its specialized security team, which performs threat hunting and responds to incidents, ensuring comprehensive protection against cyber threats.

The functions of a SOC in protecting your business

A security operations center (SOC) is the central hub for an organization's cybersecurity efforts, continuously monitoring and analyzing the security posture. The SOC monitors network activities using security information and event management (SIEM) tools to detect and respond to security incidents. This setup offers a broad view of the organization's security landscape, enabling effective management and mitigation of risks.

SOC vs. MDR: complementary forces in cybersecurity

While MDR provides targeted, endpoint-focused threat management, SOC provides a broader, strategic approach to security monitoring. Businesses might choose MDR for its direct, hands-on approach to threats, especially if they lack in-house security resources. Larger organizations, or those with more complex security needs, might lean towards establishing a SOC for a comprehensive security strategy. MDR vs. SOC can create a layered defense mechanism tailored to an organization's needs and capabilities.

Integrating MDR for enhanced endpoint security

In today's digital environment, endpoint security is more critical than ever. Managed detection and response (MDR) fills this crucial role by offering targeted protection for endpoints—laptops, servers, or mobile devices. MDR providers leverage endpoint detection and response (EDR) technologies, combined with the expertise of security analysts, to monitor suspicious activities and respond to threats swiftly. This integration ensures that any attempt to compromise an endpoint is detected and mitigated promptly, keeping your business's data and infrastructure secure.

Leveraging SOC for comprehensive cyber vigilance

The security operations center (SOC) is the cornerstone of an organization's cybersecurity framework, providing 24/7 vigilance over the network's security. The SOC identifies potential security threats in real time by aggregating data from across the network and employing sophisticated analysis through managed SIEM services. This continuous monitoring, coupled with a strategic response mechanism, enables the SOC to detect, analyze, and counteract threats, ensuring the integrity and resilience of the business's digital assets.

What are MDR and SOC?

Critical differences between MDR and SOC

MDR vs. SOC are both critical in cybersecurity, but they have different roles and ways of working:

1. MDR (managed detection and response): This is like having a specialized team on call that uses advanced tools to find and deal with cyber threats quickly. They focus on actively searching for threats, figuring out what's happening, and responding fast to stop attacks.

2. SOC (security operations center): This is like a watchtower where a team of experts monitors your network 24/7. They use many tools to monitor your systems, looking for any signs of a security breach. The SOC team identifies, investigates, and responds to potential security incidents.

Scope and focus

MDR services use advanced tools and expert knowledge to find and stop cyber threats quickly. They act fast to prevent any damage. On the other hand, a SOC looks at a broader range of security tasks and monitors an organization's entire network to catch and evaluate any possible threats.

Operational approach

MDR services actively find and stop cyber threats early by using the latest technology and methods like machine learning. They aim to predict and block attacks before they happen, offering solutions tailored to specific security problems. In contrast, SOCs mainly watch and handle an organization's security. They use different tools, such as SIEM, to collect and study information from the network. This leads to a more reactive strategy, where SOC analysts deal with threats and alerts as they come up.

Service delivery

MDR vs. SOC solutions are typically delivered as managed services, where the MDR provider manages an organization's cybersecurity operations. This often includes 24/7 monitoring, incident response, and ongoing threat assessment, allowing businesses to outsource their cybersecurity needs to specialized experts. SOC services can also be managed externally but are commonly operated in-house, especially in larger organizations. An in-house SOC involves setting up a dedicated team and infrastructure to oversee the organization's cybersecurity, providing a high degree of control over security processes and decisions.

Technology utilization

MDR providers leverage advanced technologies, including EDR (endpoint detection and response) and advanced analytics, to offer precise and efficient threat detection and mitigation. This technology-driven approach ensures that MDR services can swiftly adapt to the evolving threat landscape. SOCs, while employing advanced technologies like SIEM for data integration and analysis, often focus on a broader set of tools to monitor network security supervision and manage security data. This allows SOCs to provide a panoramic view of an organization's security posture, encompassing everything from network traffic to user behavior.

Critical differences between MDR and SOC

Top factors to consider when choosing cybersecurity services

In the digital age, where cyber threats loom more significant by the day, selecting the right cybersecurity services is more than necessary—it's a strategic imperative. The landscape between MDR vs. SOC is vast and varied. Understanding the pivotal factors that should guide your choice is crucial to ensure your defenses are robust and right-sized for your needs. Let's explore these top considerations to ensure your cybersecurity framework is potent and poised to protect.

1. Scope of services

SOC is a service that provides comprehensive monitoring, leveraging SIEM typically for a broad analysis of your security posture. MDR, conversely, generally is more focused, offering rapid detection and response to threats, mainly through EDR tools. Understanding the scope—whether you need wide-ranging surveillance (SOC) or targeted threat management (MDR).

2. Operational focus

SOCs primarily monitor security systems and alerts, aiming for advanced security oversight. However, MDR services often take a more hands-on approach to actively seeking out and mitigating threats. This operational difference is vital in determining which service aligns with your security strategy.

3. Integration with existing security

Evaluate how well the MDR vs. SOC service integrates with your security infrastructure. A managed SOC or an advanced SOC solution should seamlessly dovetail with your internal SOC and security tools, enhancing your security outcomes without redundant overlap.

4. Expertise and responsiveness

The level of expertise offered by the cybersecurity service provider, especially in managing SOC and MDR services, can significantly impact your security posture. MDR typically requires rapid response capabilities to deal with threats as they emerge, while SOC services demand continuous monitoring and analysis by seasoned security professionals.

5. Customization and scalability

Whether it's SOC or MDR, the service should be customizable to your specific needs and scalable to adapt to your organization's growth and evolving threat landscape. This flexibility ensures that the security service remains effective over time.

6. Security outcomes

Ultimately, your choice should be driven by the desired security outcomes. If you aim to have in-depth, continuous monitoring of your network to detect and respond to anomalies, a SOC service might be the best fit. MDR could offer a more suitable solution if you focus on proactively hunting threats and rapidly responding to incidents.

Top factors to consider when choosing cybersecurity services

Comparing MDR and SOC providers in the market

Choosing between MDR vs. SOC services is vital to crafting an effective cybersecurity strategy. According to Tech Target, MDR offers a focused approach to threat detection and response, utilizing expert-led analysis and rapid containment strategies to protect across various environments. In contrast, a SOC acts as the cybersecurity hub, providing broad, continuous monitoring and defense of an organization's information systems with a team of security experts. This comprehensive vigilance helps real-time incident management and reinforces compliance and security posture through expert-driven responses and remediation strategies.

Service focus

MDR providers often take a proactive, hands-on approach, focusing on rapid threat detection, investigation, and response. This usually involves leveraging advanced technologies like XDR (extended detection and response) to extend capabilities beyond traditional endpoints and cover network and cloud environments. On the other hand, SOC providers typically offer a broader scope, concentrating on continuously monitoring the organization's security posture by utilizing SIEM (security information and event management) systems to aggregate and analyze data across the network.

Operational approach

SOC services are known for their emphasis on monitoring, often providing round-the-clock surveillance of network activities, identifying anomalies, and generating security alerts. They aim to offer comprehensive visibility into an organization's security environment. MDR services, by contrast, are generally more focused on the rapid resolution of identified threats, deploying specialized teams to address incidents as they arise.

Market offerings

The market presents a spectrum of providers, some offering dedicated MDR or SOC services, while others provide integrated MDR and SOC solutions. When evaluating providers, it's essential to consider the depth and breadth of their services. Some providers might offer a more integrated approach, blending the proactive, responsive nature of MDR with the extensive monitoring capabilities of SOC.

Differences in services

The critical differences between MDR vs. SOC often lie in their execution and deliverables. MDR services are typically characterized by their agility and speed in responding to threats, frequently delivering more tailored, immediate outcomes. SOCs, in contrast, might focus on providing a comprehensive overview of an organization's security health, often taking a more systematic approach to security management.

Choosing the right provider

Deciding between MDR or SOC—or a combination of both—depends on your organization's specific security needs, existing capabilities, and risk profile. An MDR provider offering XDR functionalities might suit organizations seeking targeted, rapid response capabilities. Conversely, organizations requiring extensive, continuous monitoring across multiple security layers might lean towards SOC services, especially those incorporating advanced SIEM technologies.

Comparing MDR and SOC providers in the market

Empowering your cybersecurity with Sage

In the ever-evolving digital landscape, where threats loom at every corner, Sage stands as a beacon of robust cybersecurity solutions. With a keen eye on the latest cybersecurity trends and a deep understanding of the nuanced differences between MDR vs. SOC services, Sage ensures your digital assets are safeguarded with precision and agility.

Our approach is designed to offer the best of both worlds: the extensive oversight of SOC services combined with the proactive, targeted interventions of MDR. By choosing Sage, you align your organization with a partner adept at navigating the complexities of cybersecurity, ensuring your defenses are comprehensive and adaptable to the dynamic nature of cyber threats.

Empowering your cybersecurity with Sage

Final thoughts

In cybersecurity, where threats evolve with daunting speed, the strength of your defenses can make all the difference. Sage is at the forefront, offering expertise, technology, and vigilance that transforms your security posture from reactive to impregnable. Contact us and set the course for a secure, resilient future. Together, we'll tailor a cybersecurity strategy that defends and empowers your business, turning potential vulnerabilities into bastions of strength. 

Frequently asked questions

What's the difference between SOC and MDR?

SOC, which stands for security operations center, primarily focuses on monitoring and responding to security incidents. At the same time, MDR often takes a proactive approach by actively hunting for threats and providing response capabilities.

How does MDR service differ from SOC service?

MDR service providers typically offer a more comprehensive approach to cybersecurity by combining detection, response, and remediation capabilities, while SOC service providers mainly focus on monitoring and incident response.

What is the role of a SIEM in SOC and MDR services?

SIEM (Security Information and Event Management) solutions are often utilized in MDR vs. SOC services to collect, correlate, and analyze security event data to help identify potential threats and provide actionable insights for security teams.

How does XDR relate to MDR and SOC services?

Extended Detection and Response (XDR) solutions aim to provide a more integrated and automated approach to threat detection and response, enhancing the capabilities of both MDR and SOC services in defending against advanced cyber threats.

What do security service providers offer regarding SOC and MDR services?

Security service providers offer a range of solutions, including SOC as a service, MDR as a service, and managed security service offerings to help organizations enhance their cybersecurity posture and defend against evolving threats.

How can internal SOC teams benefit from MDR services?

Internal SOC teams can benefit from MDR services by leveraging the additional resources, expertise, and advanced technologies MDR service providers provide to enhance their threat detection and response capabilities.

Focus on your business and leave your IT needs to us...

< 10 mins
average response time
customer retention rate
customer satisfaction score